Pagination Not Working Properly

Hello, GP Team!

Quick question, it seems that the pagination toggled through WP Show posts isn't working when users try to click to a new page. The URL changes but the actual posts don't change. It's not happening on all the landing pages. I'm sharing an example of a page where the error kicks in and one where it doesn't.

**Pagination Error** (Posts Don't Change)
https://twobrokewatchsnobs.com/new-releases/

**No Pagination Error** (Posts Change)
https://twobrokewatchsnobs.com/watch-reviews-by-baird-brown/

Please try the pagination out on the above URLs and let me know if there is any other details I can provide.

Thank you so much!