Hi David,
The Category Archives were never set to anything different.
What happened was, I originally used “Pages” to create new pages to link to the corresponding menu names. This was my mistake, not understanding how best to set up the menu. I thought these new pages would populate the related blog posts, but I realized they wouldn’t.
So then I deleted those pages. And I linked the Category Archives, Which works fine.
My only issue now is that Google is still finding those old Pages I created. Is there an area in WP to fix this?
Thanks