Hi Leo:
Sorry if I wasn’t clear. I hadn’t noticed the issue until after I activated GP Premium and disabling GP Premium did not solve the problem. Switching themes didn’t work either. Twenty Seventeen didn’t even show the toolbar anymore.
After posting my support request I disabled all plugins except BuddyPress and reactivated them one by one and it is working now. Strange because I am using the same plugins on a localhost/test installation and they didn’t cause issues, but deactivating and reactivating seems to have worked. Hopefully it will stay working lol.
Thank you for your reply and assistance.