Hi, it did not work on the live website which is why I was reaching out because it does work correctly for all other fields in both the preview and the live website. It has been set to required this whole time and I just realized today it wasn’t actually requiring it so i set to optional and back to required just to try to refresh it and it didn’t work. I will reach out to woocommerce now, but I really think they will push me back to the theme creator as i’m sure not every user of woocommerce has this problem, it’s much more likely to just be related to your theme, don’t you think?